Alex Murdaugh’s lawyers ask judge to dismiss murder indictments
Alex Murdaugh’s defense is challenging the murder indictments ahead of a retrial. Here’s what the motion asks the judge to decide.
Alex Murdaugh’s lawyers are asking a South Carolina judge to dismiss the murder indictments in the deaths of his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul. The request was scheduled for a Nov. 13 hearing before Judge Debra McCaslin in Lexington. The defense says a state investigator gave grand jurors incorrect information about physical evidence. Prosecutors say other evidence supported the charges. WIS News 10 reported that the defense cited a trial transcript in which the investigator said he first saw the confirmatory testing report after Murdaugh was indicted. Associated Press report on the motion · Court assignment order
How the case got back to court
The South Carolina Supreme Court ordered a new trial in May after finding that former court clerk Rebecca Hill improperly influenced the jury in the 2023 murder trial. South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson said his office would retry the case. Murdaugh denies killing his wife and son and is serving prison time for separate financial crimes. South Carolina Supreme Court, opinion 28329 · Attorney general’s statement · Associated Press
What the defense motion could change
The May ruling concerned the fairness of the 2023 trial. The current motion concerns information given to the grand jury that issued the charges in the first place. An indictment is the formal accusation that starts the criminal case. If the judge dismisses these indictments, prosecutors could seek new ones from a grand jury, according to AP. Jury selection in the retrial is scheduled for April 2027 in Sumter County. Associated Press · WTOC on the retrial schedule
Trust & transparency
How we handled this story
Court records and the state attorney general confirm the retrial. The motion and response are attributed to the parties, with coverage from AP and WIS.
Grounded in this reporting
Ask Newsmerica
Ask about this article. Answers quote the closest published passages and link back to their sources.
This tool retrieves article passages; it does not add outside facts.Keep exploring






