Fifth Circuit upholds block on enforcing federal pregnancy protections against Texas

The Fifth Circuit rejected counting House members by proxy for a quorum. Here’s who the Texas injunction covers and how the case reached the full court.

Exterior arches of the John Minor Wisdom courthouse along a tree-lined brick walkway
The John Minor Wisdom U.S. Court of Appeals Building in New Orleans in 2014. File photo. Carol M. Highsmith / Library of Congress. Cropped and resized.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit on Friday upheld an injunction blocking federal enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the State of Texas. The full court concluded that the House had counted absent lawmakers toward a quorum by proxy when it passed the spending package containing the law. The decision links a dispute over how Congress conducts a vote to a concrete question for employees of the state.

The Nov. 20 opinion in case No. 24-10386 separates the court’s constitutional reasoning from the order it affirmed. The majority examined how the entire 2023 spending package cleared the House. The permanent injunction covers enforcement of one part of that package, the pregnancy accommodations law, against one employer, the State of Texas. The lower court declined to issue the broader declaratory relief Texas had requested.

Why a vote by proxy became a quorum case

A quorum is the minimum number of lawmakers a chamber needs to conduct business under the Constitution. Article I, Section 5 says that a majority of each house constitutes a quorum. It also gives the House and Senate the power to determine their own rules. The dispute was about where that rulemaking authority ends when members are physically away from the chamber.

The House adopted a proxy procedure during the COVID-19 pandemic. Members could designate a colleague to vote for them, and the House counted those represented by proxy as present for establishing a quorum. It used that procedure when it approved the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 in December 2022. The spending act included the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.

The majority concluded that members had to be present in person for the quorum at issue. It also held that the enrolled-bill rule, a doctrine that generally limits judicial inquiry into whether an authenticated law made its way through Congress, did not foreclose review of this challenge. Dissenting judges disagreed with the majority’s approach, including how much deference courts owe the House over its own procedures.

That distinction between presence and voting matters. The court addressed whether someone who was away from the chamber could count as present to create the quorum in the first place. For another congressional vote, the first questions would be which rule applied, whether a quorum existed under that rule, and what legal relief a challenger actually sought.

Who the injunction covers

Start with the employer. Texas sued in its capacity as a state employer. That is the injury the district court addressed, and it is the relief the Fifth Circuit upheld. The decision gives a Texas state employee and a private-sector employee in the same city different reasons to read the order. A statewide job location alone does not answer whether the injunction covers the employer.

For the federal framework, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s guide explains that covered employers generally must provide reasonable accommodations for known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions, subject to undue hardship. The agency lists adjustments such as access to water, changes in seating and breaks as possible examples. Which accommodation is appropriate depends on the circumstances.

The same EEOC guide distinguishes the PWFA from other workplace protections, including federal prohibitions on pregnancy discrimination. That distinction matters because the court’s injunction names the PWFA. A worker trying to understand a specific accommodation request can start by identifying the applicable law, the employer and the dates of the request.

The court’s reasoning could be cited in a different case about a different provision. A party seeking relief would still need to show how it is affected and obtain an order. Friday’s judgment resolves the appeal in this case. Readers following another employer or another law should look for that party’s own order before applying the Texas injunction to it.

How the case reached the full court

The Northern District of Texas issued its ruling in February 2024. A divided Fifth Circuit panel then reversed in August 2025. The appeals court granted rehearing before the full court and vacated the panel opinion. The Nov. 20 ruling affirmed the original district court judgment. Those steps explain why articles from different stages of the same case describe different outcomes.

The next developments to watch are entries on the docket, including any action on the mandate, a request to pause enforcement of the ruling, or a petition for Supreme Court review. The most useful records for workers are the operative order, the identity of their employer and the EEOC’s current guidance. Follow developments through the Newsmerica Politics desk.

Trust & transparency

How we handled this story

Verified

Read the Nov. 20 en banc opinion and relief, the August 2025 panel opinion, the district court decision and the EEOC description of the federal law.

Grounded in this reporting

Ask Newsmerica

Ask about this article. Answers quote the closest published passages and link back to their sources.

This tool retrieves article passages; it does not add outside facts.

Keep exploring

More from Newsmerica

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *