Colorado judge finds ICE violated release order, declines further action

Judge Charlotte Sweeney found civil contempt over an immediate re-arrest. The order explains why ICE’s later compliance led her to close the case.

Exterior of the Alfred A. Arraj U.S. Courthouse in Denver
The Alfred A. Arraj U.S. Courthouse in Denver, photographed April 21, 2023. Archival photo. Xnatedawgx / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Cropped and resized.

A federal judge in Colorado found that Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials violated her order releasing Ramon Quintero Alvarez when agents took him back into custody immediately after letting him go. U.S. District Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney issued her written ruling Nov. 18 and declined to take further action after ICE told the court under oath that it had stopped the immediate re-detention practice.

The order finds that ICE official Nichole Black and the government respondents were in civil contempt before Nov. 9. It also says the respondents cured that contempt by ending the practice. Quintero Alvarez had already been released by the time Sweeney issued the written decision, and she directed the clerk to close his case.

A release, a re-arrest and two hearings

Sweeney ordered Quintero Alvarez released on Oct. 20 in a habeas case, a proceeding through which someone in government custody can challenge the legality of their detention. The government later told the court it released him on Oct. 27 and immediately detained him again. Its Nov. 3 status report said he remained in custody and that government lawyers would not file a brief arguing that the renewed detention was lawful.

Sweeney held a hearing on Nov. 4. The order recounts testimony from Black, an assistant field office director for ICE in Denver, who said she knew about the release order. She believed at the time that taking Quintero Alvarez into a public area before re-arresting him complied with it. Government counsel did not defend his continued detention at the hearing. A court minute entry records that the judge directed his release by 2 p.m. that day.

The court held a second evidentiary hearing on Nov. 9. Nathan Rasper, ICE’s Denver field office director, testified about the instructions that had led to the practice and said he directed it to stop after the first hearing. Sweeney described his commitment going forward as extending beyond Quintero Alvarez to people ordered released by that court. The ACLU of Colorado’s case page, which reflects its role as a friend of the court, brings together filings and the hearing transcript.

What the judge decided about contempt

The order lays out three questions for civil contempt. Was a valid order in place? Did the people subject to it know about it? Did they disobey it? Sweeney said the record satisfied each element by clear and convincing evidence. The release order was on the record, Black testified that she knew of it, and the government’s own status report described the immediate re-detention.

ICE’s account of why it adopted the approach also appears in the order. Rasper testified that he believed ICE had statutory authority to re-arrest some people after court-ordered releases, including where he understood the reason for release to be a technical issue with paperwork. Black’s interpretation was that an actual release into a public area could be followed by a new arrest. Sweeney rejected that reasoning as applied to Quintero Alvarez and concluded that his immediate re-detention defeated the court’s order.

Sweeney treated Rasper’s sworn testimony that ICE had stopped the practice as an affirmative step toward compliance. That is why the ruling can find contempt for the conduct that had already occurred and decline to issue a further sanction. The judge also denied remaining requests as moot because Quintero Alvarez was already out of custody.

The record points to a practice beyond one arrest

The order recounts testimony about immediate re-detentions in other Colorado cases. A government status report, described in the ruling, eventually identified 18 cases. That figure concerns the cases reported in response to the court’s inquiry. The contempt finding in this order centers on the government’s handling of Quintero Alvarez’s Oct. 20 release order.

Rasper testified that if ICE identifies issues in a future habeas release matter, it would bring them to the court under the process set out in a memorandum governing those releases. That is a practical consequence of the testimony: questions about continued detention would go before the judge through that process, giving the court an opportunity to address them.

Reuters’ coverage also reports that Sweeney declined to take further action after finding the practice had ceased. The written order and the hearing record give readers the basis for that decision. For more on other recent changes in immigration administration, see Newsmerica’s coverage of the proposed H-1B review rule. That proposal concerns a separate part of the immigration system.

Trust & transparency

How we handled this story

Verified

The Nov. 18 signed order, November hearing record and independent reporting support the chronology, contempt finding, agency testimony and disposition.

Grounded in this reporting

Ask Newsmerica

Ask about this article. Answers quote the closest published passages and link back to their sources.

This tool retrieves article passages; it does not add outside facts.

Keep exploring

More from Newsmerica

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *